Moral and economic madness
- Details
- Published on Sunday, 29 November -0001 16:00
- Written by editor
What do piping plovers, deep-sea drilling, Prairie floods and a $16-billion dam have in common?In each case, governments have pushed ahead with major decisions despite concerns about the ecosystems and people that would bear the brunt of the impacts.
They’re also each the subject of recent must-read stories from our crack team of reporters here at The Narwhal.
First let’s start with the plover, an adorable and endangered bird that weighs about eight toonies and is the size of a ping pong ball. Plovers were considered extinct in Ontario for decades, but thanks to conservation efforts they started reappearing on Sauble Beach, back in 2007, on the eastern shores of Lake Huron.
Alas, they’re not out of the sand dunes just yet. In fact, those sand dunes plovers rely on to make their nests have been raked over as the Town of South Bruce Peninsula tries to make the world’s second-longest freshwater beach more appealing to the one-million-plus tourists that flock to it each year.
Even a $100,000 fine from the province hasn’t deterred the local government, which is prepared to go all the way to Canada’s Supreme Court in a fight that could have huge implications for species protections in Ontario and across the country. Go here to read reporter Fatima Syed’s incredible yarn, which was just recognized by Longreads as one of its five top features of the week.
One big story that’s been making headlines this week is the Trudeau government’s approval of the Bay du Nord deep-sea oil and gas drilling project off the coast of Newfoundland and Labrador. Here’s a not-so-nice dose of the climate stakes at play: the OK came the same week António Guterres, secretary-general of the United Nations, called decisions to invest in new fossil fuel projects “moral and economic madness.”
(Separately, Federal Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault warned Canadian energy giant Suncor that a new oilsands project the company wants to launch in Alberta “may not align” with Canada’s climate change goals and is not likely to be approved as currently proposed.)
There’s no shortage of concerns over the federal process for Bay du Nord, which some say ignored Fisheries and Oceans Canada research on the project’s environmental risks in favour of oil and gas interests out east. Senior editor Elaine Anselmi has all the details.
Climate extremes are already upending the lives of 18 residents in Lehigh, Alta. The community, which sits along the Red Deer River northeast of Calgary, won’t exist come 2024. Lehigh is part of a flood zone in the Drumheller Valley, a region all too familiar with experiencing wicked flooding events.
As climate change contributes to increasingly severe and more frequent extreme weather events in the area, the town of Drumheller has decided that fortifying Lehigh from future floodwaters just isn’t worth the cost. And that means the end of what residents thought would be their “forever home,” Drew Anderson reports.
Does the $16 billion Site C dam project infringe on Treaty 8 Rights? That was set to be the key question in a B.C. Supreme Court “mega trial” due to begin last month. Instead, West Moberly First Nations and public utility BC Hydro have pressed pause to negotiate. Site C, a project shrouded in secrecy that’s ballooned in cost to become the most expensive hydro project in Canada’s history, is being pushed forward by the B.C. government despite lingering concerns about the stability of the dam and other geotechnical issues.
Still, there is hope that when it comes to West Moberly’s case, the government might be shifting its approach. As one legal expert told reporter Matt Simmons: “For a long time, there was denial — deny, deny, deny — and now we’re moving into an era where there’s supposed to be an acknowledgement or recognition and reconciliation.”
The Site C negotiations are a reminder that governments have the ability to listen and adapt — sometimes it just takes a lengthy legal battle to bring them to the table. As for how this dynamic will play out for the plovers and deep-sea drilling and communities ravaged by climate change … we’ll have to wait and see.
Take care and try to avoid moral and economic madness,
Arik Ligeti
Director of audience
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
BECOME A MEMBER
Note from a Narwhal
Dr. Merwan Engineer, emeritus professor at the University of Victoria, had been following The Narwhal for years and wanted to step up his support of our work.
So he reached out to our director of finance and asked: would you accept a gift of securities, like, say, bonds or publicly-traded stocks?
Well, it turns out that, thanks to our ability to issue charitable donation receipts, we’d be able to do just that. And so we sprang into action — and Merwan was able to donate shares right to The Narwhal, receive a tax receipt and avoid capital gains tax on any increase in value those shares had earned over the years. Win, win, win, amirite?
I asked Merwan what prompted him to make the leap with his gift. “You’re not just rehashing,” he said. “You’re digging deeply. Your investigative journalism has huge value added to society. It not only alerts your readership but also informs public policy in ways that are very, very important.”
Merwan highlighted some of the stellar work from our team: Sarah Cox’s groundbreaking and tenacious reporting on the Site C dam’s cost overruns and environmental risks; Emma McIntosh’s piece on the Ontario natural resources report government kept hidden until she filed a freedom of information request; and Sharon J. Riley’s years-long efforts to profile a former Alberta government scientist sounding the alarm about the reclamation mess stemming from oil and gas wells.
“I mean, those are just three of many outstanding pieces of investigative journalism. … You guys are filling a void. It’s so hard to get attention, but you are bringing more to the table, and hopefully it will permeate and have effects. I love that you’re winning awards and word is getting out there.”
Go here to learn more about how you can give a gift just like Merwan, plus all the other ways you can help bolster The Narwhal’s non-profit journalism.
This week in The Narwhal
The Alberta government spent another $22 million on unpaid land rent for oil and gas operators in 2021By Sharon J. Riley
When oil and gas companies are unable, or unwilling, to pay their land rent, the provincial government will pay it for them. More than 99 per cent of the time, Alberta never gets its money back.
READ MORE
Hold corporations accountable for reconciliation in climate rules, First Nations finance group saysBy Carl Meyer
READ MORE
Sea lice are becoming more resistant to pesticides — that’s a problem for B.C.’s beleaguered salmon farmsBy Judith Lavoie
READ MORE
This week in The Narwhal
When the destruction of your habitat prompts you to leave for greener pastures. Share this newsletter with a friend and tell them a) The Narwhal’s first-rate reporting isn’t going anywhere and b) to go sign up for our latest coverage.
r63Sign up for this newsletter
You are on this list because you signed up to receive The Narwhal’s newsletter.
You can r34.
The NarwhalSuite 634185 - 911 Yates St.Victoria, BC V8V 4Y9 Canada
Add us to your address book
Copyright © 2022 The Narwhal, all rights reserved.