The Mirage of Pension-Fund Activism
- Details
- Published on Sunday, 29 November -0001 16:00
- Written by editor
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~(((( T h e B u l l e t ))))~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A Socialist Project e-bulletin ... No. 1592 ... April 19, 2018
_____________________________________________________________
The Mirage of Pension-Fund Activism
Bob Farkas
In her 2016 book No Shortcuts: Organizing for Power in the New Gilded Age, union organizer Jane McAlevey argued that unions have repeatedly and fruitlessly searched for quick fixes to the long decline of organized labour. This hunt for a magic bullet has diverted unions from investing in the single enduring and indispensable source of working-class power: deep organizing to build workers’ collective capacities for struggle.
One alluring shortcut to renewing labour’s strength has been to try to exploit the growth of pension funds. In Canada, the United States, and other countries, these pools of workers’ retirement savings have grown, even as union density has fallen. Today, pension funds alone hold assets of nearly $41-trillion (U.S.) worldwide,... and are growing at 6 per cent a year; Canada itself is home to $1.8-trillion (U.S.) in pension-fund assets and some of the biggest pension-fund investors in the world. These funds invest in every imaginable asset around the planet – not just stocks and bonds, but schools, hospitals, airports, municipal water systems, farm land, coal deposits, and other myriad assets.
The Rise of the Working-Class Shareholder: Labor’s Last Best Weapon is only the latest in a long line of books urging unions to harness pension funds’ financial clout to advance workers’ interests. The book’s author, David Webber, is a professor in the Boston University Law School, with a deep knowledge of pension law and close ties to the U.S. union pension-activist community. Webber is firmly in labour’s camp, and is a sharp critic and opponent of the U.S. right wing. But the book’s approach epitomizes McAlevey’s argument that the search for shortcuts is a dead end.