That 49th parallel is not a stopping point

‘That 49th parallel is not a stopping point’ r1 ... Subscribe to this newsletter narwhal logo BECOME A MEMBER Shelly Boyd jumps over water near Harrop, B.C., in traditional Sinixt territory. Imagine being told you no longer exist. That your people, despite being very much alive, have been declared “extinct.”

That’s exactly what the Canadian government said of the Sinixt people in 1956.

Sixty-four years later, the Sinixt are still very much alive and well — and they’re fighting in Canada’s highest court to have their Indigenous Rights recognized.

It’s a fight I became more familiar with in September when I spoke with Shelly Boyd (pictured above), who shared the story of her people. At the time, Shelly didn’t know if she’d be able to travel to Canada for the hearing.

Sinixt territory stretches across Washington state and B.C., but the Sinixt were pushed south due to colonization, called the Arrow Lakes Tribe and then billed by both Canada and the U.S. as an “American” tribe.

That forced relocation was creating a new obstacle as COVID-19 border restrictions threatened to derail travel plans to have their voices heard in Ottawa. At stake? Nothing less than the question of whether the Sinixt hold rights in Canada.

Shelly, Derrick Lamere and Rick Desautel — the plaintiff in the case — did finally manage to enter B.C., where they quarantined in their traditional territory before making the journey to Ottawa.
Rick Desautel stands above the Slocan River. Rick Desautel stands above the Slocan River or Słuʔqín̓, which means “speared in the head,” referring to the Sinixt practice of spearing salmon. Photo: Mike Graeme / The Narwhal It was there where pandemic measures reared their ugly head: “non-essential” people would be kept out of the courtroom.

“Ironically, we’re here in a case about extinction, and we’re not allowed to be seen,” Shelly told The Narwhal’s Stephanie Wood.

The Sinixt case was launched in 2010, when Rick headed to Canada to harvest elk in his traditional territory — a deliberate effort to test the Sinixt Peoples’ Indigenous Rights.

When B.C.’s Supreme Court heard the case in 2017, the Crown went so far as to bring in an anthropologist who testified that the Sinixt had moved to the U.S. “enthusiastically.”

The presiding judge disagreed and ruled in favour of the Sinixt. The government challenged that in the B.C. Court of Appeal, losing again, before escalating the fight all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada.

The Crown’s argument? The Sinixt exercising Indigenous Rights in Canada is “incompatible with Canadian sovereignty.”

It’s a case that will not only have significant consequences for people like Shelly and Rick, but also for other Indigenous Peoples whose traditional territories span across international borders set by the colonial powers that often pushed them away from traditional lands in the first place.

We likely won’t have a verdict from the Supreme Court for at least six months, Shelly says.

For his part, Rick will be spending much of that time in B.C., close to a Sinixt village site. He’s hoping that one day he’ll be able to bring grandchildren there, where he’ll tell them: “That 49th parallel is not a stopping point in your history.”

Go here to read Steph’s story about the Sinixt, which features stunning images by photographer Mike Graeme.

Take care and fight for your rights,

Arik Ligeti
Audience Engagement Editor

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. P.S. A keen-eyed reader pointed out an error in last week’s newsletter. We said that remediation of the Clinton Creek mine was expected to take 15 years at a cost of roughly $500 million. Those are actually the numbers for Yukon’s Faro mine. We still have no idea what the timeline or financial toll will be to clean up Clinton Creek.

Note from a Narwhal We love all the feedback we get here at The Narwhal, but we were especially smitten with this note from Michèle, who just joined us as a monthly member.

“I have been so impressed with the quality of your journalism and your commitment to uncover the truth behind the environmental stories that affect us all. It is with deep gratitude that I am becoming a monthly supporter. Thank you.”

No, thank you, Michèle. It’s thanks to the support of members like you that we’re able to report on stories that often get little or no detailed attention — like this latest piece on the Sinixt.

The Narwhal currently counts 1,800 members who support us by giving whatever they can each month. And we have a very special target for the end of the year: 2,020 members in 2020.

Every new Narwhal makes a big difference. Your contributions enable us to dig into stories that would otherwise go untold. Will you help us reach 2,020 in 2020 by becoming a member today?
BECOME A NARWHAL This week in The Narwhal

‘I wanted to show them I wasn’t extinct’

Shelly Boyd touches the waters her ancestors knew at ʔ aʔ kłkəkniʔ by the ferry in Harrop, B.C. By Stephanie Wood

The Canadian government declared them extinct 64 years ago. These living, breathing Sinixt people beg to differ. Read more.

Polar Bear Week highlights absence of Arctic sea ice due to climate change

Polar bears on the west coast of Hudson Bay wait for the sea ice to freeze up By Julien Gignac
The world’s southernmost population of polar bears might be waiting longer for sea ice to form at their annual gathering in Manitoba. Read more.

When did BC Hydro really know about Site C dam stability issues? Utilities watchdog wants to know

By Sarah Cox
The B.C. Utilities Commission — the body responsible for approving increases to hydro rates necessary to pay for Site C — is seeking details about the project’s deepening geotechnical problems and worsening finances. Read more.

Opinion: Mi’kmaw lobster fishery conflict reveals confusion over who makes the rules

Mi'kmaq Fishing Rights Rally in Vancouver By Lucia Fanning and Shelley Denny

The focus on the lobster livelihood fishery and finding a dollar definition for 'moderate' misses the fact that the underlying governance gap is the crux of the issue. Read more.

What we’re reading New York Times Alberta oil wells CBC article coffee and climate change Carol Linnitt holds a Narwhal surfboard When your love of surfing and The Narwhal collide. Ride the waves and spread the word about r33

Copyright © 2020 The Narwhal, All rights reserved.
You are on this list because you signed up to receive The Narwhal newsletter.

Our mailing address is:
The Narwhal
Suite 634
185 - 911 Yates St.
Victoria, BC V8V 4Y9

Add us to your address book

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or r34.

This email was sent to s6
why did I get this? r34 r35
The Narwhal · Suite 634 · 185 - 911 Yates St. · Victoria, BC V8V 4Y9 · Canada


Login Form